Howdy, Y'all. And now for something completely different. I am not in the habit of reviewing books, but I am in the habit of speaking my mind (much to the dismay of some people). Since I said that I was going to do this, here we go.There are no graphics of stars to put here, so I will tell you that I give The Art of Manliness by Brett and Kate McKay four out of five stars. Hey, to be manly about this, I have to be honest! Don't feel bad, Dude and Dudette, top marks from me are extremely rare. So four stars is good; it means I'm glad I have it, and recommend it to other men. Keep reading and I'll explain why.
As an aside, yes, I am giving links to Amazon.com. I am not an affiliate of Amazon, so no kickbacks here. My copy came from there, and the service is reliable. (They have their electronic "Kindle" edition, but this book really needs to be held, pages flipped, smelled and so on.) Order the book and add, say, Colonel Conk's Shaving Mug (like I did), and your shipping for both items is covered. You can ask your local bookseller to carry it, of course.
Note the damaged cover. That is actually clever graphic design. This book will be a manual for your frequent reference, so it will not be pristine after the frequent use that it will have when you grab it in a "How do I..." moment. It covers many areas in a man's life, not just the "man about town" image front and center.
The Art of Manliness tells us what manliness really is, and that it has been lost in modern society. True manliness is undergoing a renaissance, and I am all in favor of that. This book fits right in. You get inspiration and instruction in manliness without preaching. Page 5 tells us that "any ruffian can turn into a proper gentleman". The term is precise, because nobody is talking about being a foppish London dandy from 1880.
Listen to me. I feel very strongly that I need to point something out because so many women are wary of men building each other up. True manliness does not gain anything from putting other people down. Women do not need to fear this book, it is positive and women are not disparaged.
I consider many of the topics in this book to be "starting points", introductions to topics that you may want to give further research. (After all, if the authors filled out every topic that they addressed, it would be a multi-volume set.) The McKays use humor to keep it interesting. Also, there are great quotes throughout that give inspiration. It covers a great deal of material.
There are many interesting bits about "traditional" manliness, things that I call trappings. For instance, double-edge (DE) razor shaving. I'm not interested in doing it the way my father and grandfather did it, but many men like the experience. If you get intrigued and want to try DE shaving, read it in the book first and then go online (hint: go here for a highly respected shave tutor). Do you know how to tie a necktie? The book has you covered, but there are instructions online to supplement it. See what I mean about starting points? For that matter, it's full circle for me, because I learned about the book through the Art of Manliness site and community. Funny how that works.
The Art of Manliness also has, amongst so many other useful things, etiquette instruction. Yes, that's a lost art. (Frankly, I think that when men act like ill-mannered brutes, ultra-feminists feel justified in referring to our entire gender as cavemen.) Spend some time with the McKays on this, I implore you. And stop smacking your food before I smack you, capice? They can save you some embarrassment. There is a mix of traditional etiquette to modern etiquette, including text messaging and the Internet. This new etiquette is long overdue!
There is a section on how to "fight like a gentleman". It describes the almost-lost self-defense art of Bartitsu, developed by E. W. Barton-Wright. While fascinating, I find the chapter to be impractical. You cannot learn it from a book. Also, in my world, you do not fight like a gentleman, you fight to win. I fight dirty because the other guy (a) has no honor, and (b) wants me dead. Sorry, Brett and Kate. But anyway, Bartitsu looks and sounds great. Again, the book is a starting point. From there, find actual instruction. Addendum: Brett tells me that "Bartitsu was meant to be more fun than practical-just good, interesting man knowledge". The same applies to a section on "how to land an airplane".
The section called "The Lover" is one I could have saved them time on because I could have written it. But I don't think the McKays would have appreciated all of the, uh, intimate details that I would describe. In fact, it's not a sex talk at all. Instead, it talks about chivalry (no, it's not dead), what message you're sending with the flowers you select for your girl, deciding if you're ready for marriage and so forth. This chapter is just in time, because what it describes is sorely lacking from modern society.
A section on kite making and paper airplane making should, frankly, have been left out because a reader needs copious illustrations and possibly videos if first-hand instruction is not available. The book is a refresher if you already know these things, though.
As you can see, the book covers a great deal of material. Hey, do you know how to tie some basic real knots instead of that jumbled mess a lot of people throw together? Check the book. Camping. Navigation. Leadership skills. Speechifying (OK, so that's my term, not theirs, I'm a cowboy after all).
The Art of Manliness ends with a chapter on "The Virtuous Man". And I'm glad, because manliness "trappings" (your razor, after shave, pocket square, clothing, things you own and things you do) are nothing without manly character. (I like the things that I call the "trappings", because physical things are powerful reminders of what you are supposed to be in life.) It involves a discussion on Ben Franklin's virtues. For me, this was the most interesting chapter in the book. But that's just me; someone else may be thrilled with the chapter on being a good father.
So there you have it. I highly recommend The Art of Manliness. (I liked it so much that they didn't even have to pay me to write this review!) Some things I already knew, and they were reinforced. There was so much more that I didn't know, and I hate to admit that because my readers expect so much of me. I'll go one further: I actually learned from it. Nicky was shocked at my admission, the guys in the crew put me on a pedestal and it actually gets embarrassing.
Women, great gift idea for the men in your lives. Men, either get one for yourselves or for other men. Or do both. So, here you go.
This is a dual post, also seen at the highly inflammatory, controversial and politically incorrect Stormbringer's Thunder.



